Who is carnegie in the book of eli

Solara is a representation of jesuss loyal disciples. However, eli proves to be the better man when he gently declines her advances. He puts eli up for the night and sends his blind, commonlaw wife, claudia jennifer beal, in to see that he is comfortable. The book of eli eli conversation with carnegie about the book. The bible he had with him was in braille and is of no use to carnegie, who finds his city falling apart now that he no longer has his soldiers to maintain order. For reference, the nuclear event of the book of eli took place 30 years before the events of. We here at cinapse have written extensively about the wandering blind swordsman who is unknown to most us filmgoers today, but who is perhaps one of cinemas all time greatest heroes. West is his oneword reply, which lands him in a fetid shell of a town that makes deadwood look like paris and is presided over by carnegie gary oldman, a man roughly elis age whos. The governors militia most likely have an education as their event was pretty recent compared to the catasrophe of the book of eli. Jan 07, 2020 the book of eli is about to celebrate its ten year anniversary on january 11, 2020.

The main character, eli, frequently protects the bible with his life, reads from it day and night, and hides its words in his heart and mind. The carnegie deli was an iconic small delicatessen chain based in new york city. The book of eli is a parable about the battle for the bible in a postapocalyptic america that speaks profoundly to the battle for the bible in contemporary america. I am forbidden by the critics little rule book from naming the volume, but if youve made a guess after seeing numerous billboards stating religion is power, you may have guessed right. God tells him to take the book west, where it will be safe. Carnegie s pride is demonstrated by how he treats his disciples and the bold ways he sits in his chairs. Carnegie gary oldman, the selfappointed despot of a makeshift town of thieves and gunmen. I do not know the answer, however i give a logical reason for carnegies actions which is the meat of the question. Eli believes that god has enabled him to have the book for a good reason. Carnegie s men are illiterate and dont have an education. Carnegie, which was someone who tried to antagonize eli for the book stayed true to his worldview which was i believe to be that of a atheistic, because he, nor his men, had no. The book of eli is not a mustread orange county register. Carnegie is a man who runs a town in a postapocalyptic united states and runs it with an iron fist with the help of his henchmen.

Heading west for reasons that only become clear later, eli happens upon a desert town run by carnegie gary oldman, returning to his psychotic baddie roots and his gang of violent lowlifes. I laughed out loud when carnegie s goons dumped a sack of books on the floor and the da vinci code and a copy of. Baptists and muslims first on black entertainment television and. Sep 09, 2012 carnegie, whom eli shot in the leg before leaving town, exults over his triumph in stealing the book from the walker eli, but his triumph ends in tragedy. Heading west for reasons that only become clear later, eli happens upon a desert town run by carnegie gary oldman, returning to his psychotic. At the end, we see eli telling the librarian that he has the book, intercut with a scene of carnegie attempting to break into the one hes been given. One of carnegie s men also uses one after the fight at carnegie s bar. We see elis faith remain steadfast as he faces many trials and tribulations, including. Book of eli caps wasteland saga with a twist the book of eli starts out with 10 minutes of dialoguefree imagery depicting the type of postapocalyptic wasteland made familiar in recent. If you have yet to see this awesome flick, then i hope this article encourages you to finally watch this rrated christian movie about what would happen if the world was devoid of the bible watch the original trailer here. It makes him wonder if perhaps eli might possess the book.

Me and my husband just watched this movie, great plot overall but the ending is a little weird, and i was wondering why everyone is after a braille bible. One of elis adventures includes meeting and taking on the ruler of a small town, carnegie gary oldman, who has a monopoly on the sale of. Washington and the hughes brothers do a good job of establishing this man and his world, and at first, the book of eli seems destined to be solemn. Although this new one has its comic book qualities, good and bad, the hugheses have stanched the blood in the book of eli, making it easier to pay attention to what else is happening on screen. The gospel according to the book of eli popmatters. To make eli state where the bible is, carnegie grabs solara by her hair, causing her pain, and then holds a handgun on her. Spoiler alert book of eli why does everyone want a bible. I dont have the right words, he says, but the book does. Feb 14, 2015 the book of eli eli conversation with carnegie about the book duration.

He was a killer from the start, not holding the reality. The book of eli suggests that such selfconfidence is not always wise. Carnegie sends his gang into the wasteland to take the book from eli, but the man proves to be a formidable foe as he makes it more than clear that if they want the book, they must first take his life. Jan 19, 2010 the gospel according to the book of eli. This is the screen used rifle and sling carried and used by don johnson in the movie a boy and his dog as well as in the book of eli. When solara first comes to seduce eli she is obviously dressed for solicitation and she says dont worry you dont have to pay.

Eli quickly disarms him of it, but returns it as a sign of trust. For reference, the nuclear event of the book of eli took place 30 years before the events of the film. He is blind and owns the last copy of the bible on earth which is in braille. Denzel washington in a world where it pays to be a loner. Carnegie, whom eli shot in the leg before leaving town, exults over his triumph in stealing the book from the walker eli, but his triumph ends in tragedy. A motion comic companion piece to the book of eli, billy tells the backstory of the films antagonist and his rise to power. After eli refuses carnegies entreaties to give him the book, and takes down a squad of his nastiest gorillas in the bargain, the two become deadly enemies, but not in the complex and complicit. Bill carnegie is the main antagonist in the 2010 postapocalyptic film the book of eli he is portrayed by actor gary oldman. A weapon aimed right at the hearts and minds of the weak and the desperate. The book of eli is an interesting but exhausting film with few humorous moments. In carnegie s stronghold, he takes down several extremely capable killers, and as he is leaving to continue his quest, right hand man redridge ray. There are times when its as if the hughes brothers are channeling sergio leone, not the least of which occurs when eli and carnegie s henchman played by ray stevenson face each other across a stretch of barren street. At the very end is eli s prayer, which to me is an archetypal example of how one can converse with god. The book of eli shifts into overdrive once carnegie s stepdaughter, solara, tries to.

When he reaches a village ruled by the powerful mobster, carnegie gary oldman, the man views elis impressive fighting skills and offers eli a place within his gang. Carnegie presses his blind lover claudia jennifer beals to send her daughter, solara mila kunis, to at least convince eli to spend the night by sleeping with him. Realizing eli is a literate man like himself, carnegie forces him to stay the night under guard. Solara joins eli on his journey, and they are chased. Eli then must try to escape along with a young woman solara. But then eli arrives at a western town ruled by carnegie gary oldman, who, like all the local overloads in westerns and gangster movies, sits behind a big desk flanked by a tall bald guy and, of course, a short scruffy. Particularly when a powerful man of god like eli is involved. Eli is the chosen one, carnegie is satan, and the prostitute is mary magdalene. Eli sneaks out of his room and carnegie has his henchmen shoot at eli, but the bullets seemingly just graze him, as if he is being protected. Nov 19, 2012 a motion comic companion piece to the book of eli, billy tells the backstory of the films antagonist and his rise to power. There is an aura of calm and assurance about this outsider that intrigues carnegie. In the book of eli, mila kunis, as solara, toughs out a wasteland journey. By the end of the film, carnegie realizes too late that he lost so many men trying to get the book, his remaining men arent enough to keep the town oppressed.

Eli prepares for a bar fight in the book of eli, a tavern serves as the social hub, dominated by carnegie and his henchmen. This leads to carnegie finding out that eli has the book he is looking fora king james bible. Ever since movie star denzel washington gave a shout out to our documentary different books, common word. The book of eli is a 2010 american postapocalyptic neowestern action film directed by the hughes brothers, written by gary whitta, and starring denzel. After carnegies blind mistress claudia brings eli food and water, carnegie orders her daughter solara to seduce eli, but he rebuffs her. However, it is not related to the movie by the same name. On his way, a man who runs a town of survivors of the apparent apocalypse runs into him and follows him to get the book. Gary oldman as carnegie is the perfect wicked biblical king, who is confronted at his end with the despair of his own godless emptiness, his empire falling down around him. After eli shoots his way out of the town, redridge is able to bargain with carnegie for solara because eli killed enough men that carnegie cant afford to lose redridge.

The crime boss is looking to expand his territory and knows that knowledge is power in a world where most people dont know how to read. Carnegie has heard that this volume can change the world because of its persuasive effects on people, which carnegie hopes to. Redridge recovers the book, with a locked flap, and gives it to carnegie, who releases solara. I need that book, i want that book, i want you to stay but if. The engineer holds a sawedoff 12gauge double barreled shotgun when eli comes into the store. He was portrayed by the academy award winning actor gary oldman, who also played norman stansfield in the professional, drexl spivey in true romance, egor korshunov in air force one, mason verger in hannibal.

Eli shoots most of carnegies men and hits carnegie in the leg with a shotgun blast. A few observations about the book of eli welcome to the. There are characters from the bible in the book of eli. Carnegie is the main antagonist of the book of eli he is portrayed by gary oldman.

Jan 15, 2010 the book of eli continues hollywoods obsession with postapocalyptic tales, and in many ways feels like it belongs in the same world as the road with its ashladen wastelands and crazed cannibals. A few observations about the book of eli welcome to. The girl sees eli s book, and when carnegie finds out he beats her mother until she reveals what she. But during their brief interlude, eli introduces solara to the concept of prayer a concept that quickly draws carnegie s attention. Eli, whose shirt is then bloody, struggles to stand and pulls a switchblade, but then goes back down again. Book of eli carnegie asks eli to stay night youtube. Spoiler alert book of eli why does everyone want a bible in the book of eli. Denzels book of moral ambiguity the michigan daily. A wound from elis gun has infected his leg and he has little time to live. The event that, in the movie, caused a hole to be torn in the sky signifies an act of nature that could destroy the ozone layer exposing the earths surface to uvb and other radiation, an extinction level event. Your thoughts on the movie if you have not yet seen the movie and dont want it to be spoilt for you then wait until you have seen it before you read any further. Its main branch, opened in 1937 near carnegie hall, was located at 854 7th avenue between 54th and 55th streets in midtown manhattan.

The book of eli has an incredible biblical message, which tells the story of elis unwavering faith as he honors god with his life and follows gods will no matter how hard the journey may be. Determined to use the book for his own gain, carnegie wages an allout war against eli. He was portrayed by gary oldman, who also portrayed norman stansfield in. This story of hannah, with which the books of samuel begin, involves eli. Book of eli, the internet movie firearms database guns in. The book of eli and the road to redemption catholic stand. He is played by actor denzel washington, who also portrayed lincoln rhyme, john creasy and robert mccall. When carnegie learns that eli possesses a bible, he means to win him over to his cause or kill him whatever it takes to gain control of that book. Eli accidentally shoots carnegie in trying to shoot the guy running in carnegie s direction. However, carnegie ha killed many people in his pursuit for the book. As eli is speaking, the camera zooms in on his eyes, and we see that eli is blind.

Eli replies pay for what, since he cant see all the visual clues that solara is. He soon forces solara to tell him if eli was reading a book, and realizes elis book is the one he wantsa bible. Yes, all the way at the end of the movie, it is revealed that not only is the book of eli a samurai film, but it is in fact a western, twistfilled zatoichi remake. The girl sees eli s book, and when carnegie finds out he beats her mother until she reveals what she saw. After finding what could be the last remaining bible and hearing a voice calling him to take it west, eli does whatever is necessary to protect the book. If you havent heard of it yet are interested then continue if you dont mind the plot being told though i recommend you see it first, good movie. Book of eli caps wasteland saga with a twist wired. The book of eli eli conversation with carnegie about the book duration. He believes that its words can be used as a weapon and will give him full ability to control of the feeble and desperate people. After finding out that eli has a bible he does mince his words and tells eli to give him the bible or be shot.

Starring denzel washington, gary oldman and mila kunis. Carnegie presses his blind lover claudia to send her daughter, solara, to at least convince eli to spend the night by sleeping with him. His journey is halted by a powerhungry man named carnegie gary oldman. Only one other man in this ruined world understands the power eli holds, and is determined to make it his own. Solara sees eli has a book, and he offers to share his food, saying grace before they eat.

Redridge entreats eli to surrender the book and eli tells redridge where he hid it. Subverted when we find out that carnegie has the real book, but cant read it, whereas eli knows the whole thing by heart. The girl sees elis book, and when carnegie finds out he beats her mother until. Eli was the high priest kohen gadol of shiloh, the secondtolast israelite judge succeeded only by samuel before the rule of the kings of israel and judah. Carnegie, though, thinks of scripture as a weapona cudgel to beat down the masses. Passing through a town the self described mayor carnegie is on the hunt for a bible, sending raider gangs out into the wastes to retrieve one with little luck due to all seemingly destroyed and the raiders never learning to read. As recounted by carnegie and eli, bibles are scarce due to a largescale book burning after the falloutmany irrationally blamed christianity as a cause of the war. Eli is the main protagonist in the 2010 dystopian postapocalyptic thrillerdrama film the book of eli. The book of eli is the first movie from albert and allen hughes the filmmaking brothers of from hell and menace ii society in nine years. Carnegie is the main antagonist in the 2010 postapocalyptic film the book of eli.

From then on, carnegie begins an insane quest to capture the book at all costs even if. Asked in the bible, bible statistics and history, old testament. Its moral ambiguity like this that sets the book of eli apart from typical, mindless action fare. His methods may be ruthless and vile, but he would use the bible to recreate civilization on earth by giving people a reason to live and work. With the bible, carnegie tells eli, he can help bring light and hope to the people. Jan 15, 2010 he asks eli to give it to him, telling eli that its words are meant to be shared.

The book of eli dvd 2009 this is probably one of the most highly underrated movies of 2010 due to the overwhelming surge of 3d films brought on by avatar which was out around the same time of this film. He asks eli to give it to him, telling eli that its words are meant to be shared. Jan 15, 2010 after finding what could be the last remaining bible and hearing a voice calling him to take it west, eli does whatever is necessary to protect the book. Eli and solara survive as promised, and the pair end their journey in san francisco, or rather just west of thereon a rocky island. Carnegie threatens to kill solara, to the dismay of redridge. After carnegie s blind mistress claudia brings eli food and water, carnegie orders her daughter solara to seduce eli, but he rebuffs her. Book of eli, the internet movie firearms database guns. Carnegie presents himself as a well composed and polite man but takes extremely brutal measures to ensure he gets his way. If we want to rule more than one small, fuckin town, we have to have it.